Home Lawn Care Bermuda vs St. Augustine Grass: Which Is Right

Bermuda vs St. Augustine Grass: Which Is Right

0
222

Choose Bermuda grass for full sun, heavy foot traffic and drought, and St. Augustine grass for yards with partial shade in warm, humid regions. Bermuda tolerates wear and dry spells better, mows short at 1 to 2 inches and can be grown from seed, while St. Augustine handles shade better, is mowed tall at about 3 to 4 inches, and is planted only as sod, plugs or sprigs.

Bermuda vs St. Augustine Grass A Comprehensive Comparison for Your Lawn

Both are warm-season grasses that grow actively in summer and go dormant or slow down in winter. This comparison draws on university extension guidance from Florida, Texas, South Carolina and Georgia, and covers sun and shade, water, traffic, mowing, fertilizer, establishment, pests and which cultivars to look for.

Bermuda vs. St. Augustine at a Glance

TraitBermuda grassSt. Augustine grass
Sun needsFull sun; poor shade toleranceMost shade-tolerant warm-season grass, but still needs about 4–6 hours of sun
Drought toleranceVery good to excellent; goes dormant and recoversGood, but less than Bermuda
Foot trafficHigh; excellent wear tolerance and recoveryLow; does not hold up to repeated traffic
Salt toleranceExcellentRelatively good
Cold toleranceModerate; some cultivars are very cold hardyLow; prone to winter injury in the upper South
TextureFine to mediumCoarse, wide blades
Mowing height1–2 inches for home lawns3.5–4 inches for standard types; 2–2.5 inches for dwarf cultivars such as Seville
How it spreadsAbove-ground stolons and underground rhizomes; aggressiveAbove-ground stolons only; easier to edge
EstablishmentSeed (common types), sod, sprigs or plugsSod, plugs or sprigs only
Main pestsNematodes, mole crickets, armyworms, sod webworms, Bermuda grass mitesSouthern chinch bugs
Main diseasesDollar spot, large patch, leaf spot, spring dead spotGray leaf spot, large patch, take-all root rot

Sun and Shade

This is usually the deciding factor. Bermuda grass needs full sun and thins quickly under trees or on the north side of buildings. Even shade-improved cultivars such as Celebration only do slightly better.

St. Augustine is the most shade-tolerant warm-season grass, but it is not a shade grass. University of Florida specialists say it still needs about 4 to 6 hours of direct sun, and the popular Floratam cultivar does not persist with less than about 6 hours. If your yard is deeply shaded, consider ground covers or mulched beds instead of any turf.

Water and Drought

Bermuda has very good to excellent drought tolerance. During long dry spells it turns brown and goes dormant, then greens up again when rain or irrigation returns. St. Augustine’s drought tolerance is rated good but lower than Bermuda’s; newer cultivars such as CitraBlue perform better than older ones like Floratam and Palmetto.

For either grass, water deeply and infrequently, about 3/4 to 1 inch per watering, then let the lawn dry before watering again. Check local watering restrictions, which are common across the South.

Foot Traffic and Wear

Bermuda is the go-to grass for athletic fields, golf courses and yards with kids and dogs, because its rhizomes and stolons repair damage quickly. St. Augustine’s coarse stolons are easily bruised and it recovers slowly, so it struggles along paths, play areas and dog runs.

Mowing and Maintenance

TaskBermudaSt. Augustine
Mowing height1–2 inches; a reel mower gives the best cut below 1 inchFloratam 3.5–4 in.; Palmetto 3–4 in.; CitraBlue 2–3 in.; Seville 2–2.5 in.
Mowing frequencyOften weekly or more in peak summerWeekly in summer, less often in spring and fall
EdgingFrequent; spreads into beds by rhizomesEasier; stolons stay above ground
ThatchBuilds thatch quickly with heavy fertilizingCan build thatch if overfed or overwatered

Mowing St. Augustine too short is one of the most common mistakes. It weakens the grass and invites weeds and chinch bugs. Keep mower blades sharp for both grasses.

Fertilizer Needs

University of Florida guidance gives these yearly nitrogen ranges in pounds per 1,000 sq ft, and notes many home lawns can use the lower end:

Region of FloridaBermudaSt. Augustine
North3–5 lb N2–4 lb N
Central4–6 lb N2–5 lb N
South5–7 lb N4–6 lb N

In short, Bermuda generally needs more nitrogen than St. Augustine. Excess nitrogen on St. Augustine, especially in spring and fall, increases large patch disease. Follow a soil test and your state’s recommendations.

Establishment: Seed, Sod and Plugs

Common Bermuda grass can be seeded at about 1 to 2 lb of hulled seed per 1,000 sq ft. Hybrid Bermudas such as Tifway, TifSport and Celebration do not come true from seed and are planted from sod, sprigs or plugs.

St. Augustine is established only vegetatively, from sod, plugs or sprigs. Seed is not a practical option. Read more in our guide to St. Augustine grass seed and planting options.

When to plant

  • Bermuda: late spring to early summer, when soil is warm, gives the fastest establishment. In south Florida it can be planted most of the year.
  • St. Augustine: late spring through summer in most areas, avoiding cold snaps and the hottest, driest weeks. In south Florida, late fall through spring is also used.

Pests and Diseases

Bermuda grass

  • Nematodes are the most serious problem, and no cultivar is resistant.
  • Mole crickets are a major pest in sandy soils.
  • Armyworms, sod webworms and Bermuda grass mites can cause patchy damage.
  • Diseases: dollar spot, large patch, leaf spot and spring dead spot.

St. Augustine grass

  • Southern chinch bugs are the main pest, causing yellow-to-brown patches in hot, dry, sunny areas. Some populations resist common insecticides, and Floratam has largely lost its original chinch bug resistance.
  • Gray leaf spot appears in rainy summer weather, especially with heavy nitrogen.
  • Large patch shows up in spring and fall as circular brown areas.
  • Take-all root rot causes thinning and yellowing in wet periods.

Weed Control and Herbicide Sensitivity

St. Augustine is sensitive to many herbicides, which can stunt or discolor it. Always choose products labeled for St. Augustine. Extension guidance warns against applying atrazine to Floratam above 85°F and against broadleaf herbicides when temperatures exceed about 90°F or during spring green-up. Bermuda tolerates a wider range of lawn herbicides, but always read the label.

A thick, properly mowed lawn is the best weed defense for both grasses. See our guide on how to get rid of crabgrass for a common summer weed.

Popular Cultivars

GrassCultivarNotes
BermudaTifway, TifSport, TifGrandFine-textured hybrids for high-maintenance lawns and sports turf
BermudaCelebrationFine texture, good traffic tolerance, slightly better in light shade
BermudaTifTufVery drought tolerant, holds color later into fall
BermudaLatitude 36, NorthBridgeCold-hardy choices for the transition zone
St. AugustineFloratamMost widely used in Florida; coarse; needs about 6+ hours of sun; poor cold tolerance
St. AugustinePalmettoSemi-dwarf
St. AugustineCitraBlueBlue-green, better drought tolerance, highly weed-competitive
St. AugustineRaleighMost cold-tolerant St. Augustine
St. AugustineProVistaGlyphosate-tolerant, allowing easier weed control

Which Grass Should You Choose?

Your situationBetter choice
Full sun all dayBermuda
4–6 hours of sun, scattered treesSt. Augustine
Kids, dogs, sportsBermuda
Frequent drought or watering limitsBermuda
Coastal Gulf or Florida humidity, low trafficSt. Augustine
Upper South or transition zone wintersCold-hardy Bermuda
Want to seed rather than sodCommon Bermuda
Want less edging along bedsSt. Augustine

Can You Mix Bermuda and St. Augustine?

Extension sources do not recommend mixing them. The two grasses look very different, need different mowing heights and tend to split a yard into zones: Bermuda takes over sunny areas through aggressive rhizomes and stolons, while St. Augustine holds the shadier spots. If Bermuda is invading St. Augustine, Georgia extension guidance lists spot-spraying with glyphosate as the most effective removal method (it kills any grass it touches), with ethofumesate plus atrazine as a selective option. Always follow product labels.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is better, Bermuda or St. Augustine?

Neither is better everywhere. Bermuda is better for full sun, traffic and drought; St. Augustine is better for partial shade and low-traffic lawns in warm, humid areas.

Which grass takes over the other?

In full sun, Bermuda usually wins because it spreads above and below ground. In shade, St. Augustine tends to hold its ground.

Can you grow St. Augustine from seed?

No. St. Augustine is planted from sod, plugs or sprigs. Bermuda is the one you can seed.

Which grass needs less water?

Bermuda has better drought tolerance and can go dormant during dry spells and recover.

Which handles salt better near the coast?

Both have decent salt tolerance, with Bermuda generally rated higher. Learn what happens with road and deicing salt in our article on putting salt on grass.

Should I overseed Bermuda in winter?

Some homeowners overseed dormant Bermuda with ryegrass for winter color. See ryegrass pros and cons for overseeding before you decide. St. Augustine is not usually overseeded.

The Bottom Line

Pick Bermuda for sunny, busy, drought-prone yards where you do not mind frequent mowing and edging. Pick St. Augustine for warm, humid lawns with some shade and light traffic, and mow it tall. For more on each grass, read why choose Bermuda grass, compare other Florida grass types, review our tips for a healthy lawn, or browse all lawn care guides.

Shade is often the deciding factor. UF/IFAS Extension rates bermudagrass as having poor shade tolerance and notes that it spreads aggressively by stolons and rhizomes into beds. Texas A and M AgriLife describes St. Augustinegrass as the most shade-tolerant warm-season turfgrass, though it still needs at least 4 to 6 hours of light a day, and it is established from sod, plugs or sprigs because seed is not available.

Sources

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.